Detroit’s Affordable Housing Gap: Opportunities for Investors
Detroit’s housing market is at a turning point.
Demand for affordable homes far outweighs supply, but while there’s great potential for investors, navigating the challenges of this market is not for the faint of heart.
If you’re looking to expand your portfolio in Detroit, here’s what you need to know about the realities of new construction, the lessons from high-profile missteps, and why renovating distressed properties may be smarter than opting for new builds.
The Unmatched Demand for Affordable Housing
Detroit is facing an unparalleled need for affordable housing as rents rise and homeownership remains inaccessible for many. According to recent data:
- The city still has vast swaths of vacant land, but building new homes is prohibitively expensive.
- A new construction single-family home costs approximately $450,000 to build, including $336,000 in base construction costs. This far exceeds Detroit’s 2024 average home sale price of $87,500, creating an affordability gulf for prospective buyers.
- Multifamily units are relatively more feasible, averaging $304,000 per unit, but even these face financial hurdles.
It’s a stark reality when a city like Detroit, known for its affordable housing history, struggles to meet the basic needs of the people who live here.
Why New Construction is a Minefield
Even for developers with deep pockets and access to resources, new builds in Detroit are fraught with challenges.
Case in point:
- The Gilbert Family Foundation’s Affordable Housing Project:
Designed as a showcase for manufactured homes, the $5 million project in Corktown fell victim to delays, skyrocketing home prices, and regulatory headaches.
Despite its high-profile backers and a clear mission, costs ballooned to $500,000 for some homes–pricing out its target audience of low- to moderate-income buyers.
For smaller investors, the barriers are even higher:
- High Building Costs: Construction material costs have surged by 118%–240% since 2020, making new builds financially unfeasible in many neighborhoods.
- Permitting and Infrastructure: Navigating Detroit’s complex permitting and utility hookup process often leads to long delays and additional costs.
- Appraisal Gaps: The average home sales price in Detroit doesn’t support the high costs of new builds, resulting in appraisal challenges.
The bottom line?
Unless you have unmatched expertise and the ability to build at scale without massive cost overruns, new construction may be a financial sinkhole.
The Smarter Play for Investors
While new builds come with significant risks, the demand for affordable housing still presents immense opportunities for investors.
The key is to adapt your strategy to Detroit’s market realities.
1. Renovate and Repurpose
Detroit’s real bread and butter lies in its large inventory of distressed properties. Renovating these homes can often provide a far better ROI than new construction.
- Buying undervalued homes in neighborhoods outside high-priced areas like Corktown offers opportunities for profitability. Consider areas like North End, Cornerstone Village, and Morningside, where acquisition costs are lower.
- Focus on upgrading these properties to a standard that appeals to renters or move-in-ready buyers, but avoid over-renovating. Luxury upgrades won’t deliver ROI in a market focused on affordability.
2. Favor Multifamily Over Single-Family
Multifamily properties continue to be a more realistic option for meeting housing demand while maintaining profitability:
- Building costs for multifamily units are roughly $150,000 less than single-family properties, making them more cost-effective.
- Multifamily developments also qualify for a broader range of subsidies and financing tools, including Low-Income Housing Tax Credits (LIHTC) and municipal funding.
3. Prioritize Practicality Over Fluff
Detroit residents need functional, high-quality homes more than premium finishes. Skipping unnecessary extras like high-end oversized garages or elaborate landscaping can keep your projects on budget while targeting the area’s real needs.
Lessons from High-Profile Challenges
Gilbert’s stalled project in Corktown highlights important lessons for every investor:
- Even billionaires can find Detroit’s housing regulations and costs difficult to manage. For smaller-scale investors, the takeaway is clear–start with projects that align with your expertise and manageable risk.
- The demand for affordable housing will not be met by one-size-fits-all solutions. Instead, targeted, neighborhood-specific investments in renovations and smaller-scale developments can provide consistent returns.
The Path Forward
Detroit’s housing gap represents a market that’s both challenging and full of potential.
Investors ready to tackle this unique landscape must focus on affordability, market demand, and smart risk management.
Stick to strategies that match your skill set, and remember that the city’s high demand means there’s plenty of opportunity to deliver value while safeguarding your returns.
Want to find out about exclusive off-market rental investments in Detroit? Contact us for a list of our turnkey BRRR properties.